I’m not letting you off the hook, but let me ask you this. Are your goals too high?
You have a goal, and perhaps you haven’t achieved it. None of us like this. Yet, there are a couple of conclusions you could come to.
You could conclude that it’s a fail. That you had the wrong strategy to get there, or your delivery of the strategy was inadequate. This leads you to the idea that “we need to do something differently.”
Or what if the problem is the goal itself? You instead consider, was it unrealistic or simply too ambitious? You simply set the bar too high.
Neither conclusion is necessarily wrong. The problem is reaching it too quickly.
I’d like to suggest another possibility. You’re looking at the wrong thing. Don’t look at the goal, but instead consider, how are you measuring it?
Now at this point you might be thinking, “hang on, I thought I was measuring it…I set SMART objectives.”
This is exactly the challenge, and I see it a lot. You’re collapsing your objectives* and measures. Instead, look at them as different pieces of strategic information.
An objective or goal should express the outcome you want to achieve in the future. It might look like this, “Dramatically increase customer retention.”
Then your measure should answer the question: how do we know if we’ve achieved it? In this case, you’d naturally measure “percentage of customers retained.”
And finally, your measure goes hand-in-glove with a target. Whereas the measure tells you what to look at, your target tells you how much, how often or by when. It gives you “the number” to aim for, such as “95% of customers retained.”
Your measures and targets are your objective’s data. You can look for more data on your objective, from different angles, by continuing to ask the measurement question, “how else would we know….?”
There’s also something else to consider. These are useful lag indicators. But measures can also look ahead and help you anticipate if you look for leading indicators. Ask, “what contributes to this objective?” This might be a process, skill or behaviour. Then measure that. This might look like, “Percentage of customer accounts receiving a quarterly review.”
Using several carefully crafted measures gives you a broader understanding of progress towards your objective. They give you better information about what’s working, where the gaps are, and therefore where and how to intervene. Rarely does one measure tell the whole story.
So back to the original question, are your goals or objectives too high? Probably not. But your target might be.
Examine the measure and the bar you’ve set. Are you looking at several measures that tell a broader story?
Look at both leading and lagging indicators. Understand where you’re making progress as thoroughly as where you’re falling short.
Then zero in on what the evidence is telling you. Where should you double down on strengths? Where do you need to do something differently?
Before you lower the ambition or change the strategy, make sure your measures are telling you the whole story. Then you can make better decisions about what to do next.
* I use objective and goal interchangeably. The most important consideration is to choose your terminology (goal or objective) and stick with it consistently.
This writing builds on ideas explored in my earlier article, Pragmatic Objectives, about making objectives clear and useful for execution.
